Video: Oakland has struggled for years to rebuild its police department, despite repeated commitments to increase staffing. (Sources: NBC News Bay Area, Grandmaster Flash. Montage by Oakland Report)
Editors’ note: This article was originally posted by Oakland resident Rajni Mandal on her Substack page. Oakland Report is republishing it with Mandal’s permission for our readers to consider. Subscribe to Rajni Mandal’s Public Safety Updates to receive her articles directly.
Oakland remains far below its goal of 700 sworn officers
Oakland has struggled for years to rebuild its police department, despite repeated commitments to increase staffing. Measure NN established a goal of 700 sworn officers, yet the department remains far below that number.1 For residents who expected improvements in police services, the lack of progress has been frustrating.
Recent staffing reports help explain why. Recruiting new officers is only part of the challenge. Training, retention, working conditions, and long-term medical leave all affect how many officers are ultimately available to serve the city.
Subscribe to Oakland Report (it’s free).
A staffing problem years in the making
OPD’s sworn staffing has declined sharply over the past five years.2 Although the department made gains in 2023 and 2024, those improvements proved temporary as departures continued to outpace hiring.

Oakland’s 2024 budget crisis made matters worse. The city reduced authorized police staffing and canceled two scheduled academies, eliminating nearly $7 million in funding.34 While the staffing reductions did not involve immediate layoffs, canceling the academies limited OPD’s ability to replace departing officers.
The city later restored 78 frozen positions and funded five academies over the following two years.56 But rebuilding the recruitment and training pipeline takes time, and the interruption made it harder to reverse the staffing decline.
The scale of the challenge was already apparent. An April 2025 city-commissioned study estimated that OPD needed 877 sworn officers to meet basic patrol and investigation responsibilities, far more than the city had authorized or funded.7
Two months later, Oakland’s finance department presented city council with staffing projections showing just how difficult rebuilding the department would be, even with additional police academies.8
Line chart of four Oakland finance department projections of sworn police staffing from May 2025 to late 2029, labeled by monthly attrition and academies per year. Projection 1 stays flat near 646 officers; projections 2, 3 and 4 rise to roughly 780, 740 and 890.

The projections exposed a fundamental problem: new officers were entering the department at roughly the same pace that experienced officers were leaving. Even an ambitious academy schedule might do little more than replace departing personnel.
More than a year later, the department’s hiring and attrition figures show how persistent that problem remains.
Flow diagram: the Oakland Police Department started January 2026 with 603 officers, added 37 and lost 39, and had 601 officers in September 2026, a net change of minus 2.

Despite expanded recruitment and renewed academy funding, Oakland has yet to achieve sustained staffing growth. The challenge is not simply attracting applicants, but building a workforce that grows faster than it shrinks.
Recruiting officers is only the beginning
Across OPD’s three most recent graduating academies, approximately half of the recruits who began training ultimately graduated. Those graduates must still complete field training before becoming fully trained officers.

Police academy training is demanding by design. Recruits must demonstrate proficiency in physical fitness, defensive tactics, firearms, academics, and emergency vehicle operations.9
At an October 19 meeting of the Measure NN oversight commission, deputy chief Anthony Tedesco described an unexpected challenge: younger recruits increasingly arrive with limited independent driving experience, making it harder to develop advanced driving skills within the academy’s training schedule.1011
Improving graduation rates may therefore require better preparation before recruits enter the academy, not simply larger incoming classes.
The cost of police academies has also been controversial. During Oakland’s 2025 budget deliberations, councilmember Janani Ramachandran questioned whether funding additional academies was cost-effective when relatively few recruits were graduating.12
The issue resurfaced at the November 17 public safety committee meeting, when councilmember Rowena Brown asked whether OPD realized savings when academies enrolled or graduated fewer recruits than anticipated.13 OPD explained that unused trainee salary funding can help support subsequent academies.
Meanwhile, recruitment efforts are expanding.14 OPD has increased outreach to Oakland schools and colleges, partnered with Merritt College, introduced applicant webinars and physical agility workshops, and pursued additional pathways through its cadet and lateral recruitment programs.15161718
These initiatives may improve the number and preparedness of applicants. Whether they translate into higher graduation rates and more officers remains to be seen.
Share this with someone you know.
Why officers leave
Two ranked lists of reasons officers gave for leaving the Oakland Police Department. March 2026 report: heavy discipline, commute, NSA oversight. November 2026 report: family, city/OPD leadership, work-life balance, staffing/resources.19

Recruiting new officers is only part of the challenge. Oakland must also retain experienced personnel, and recent exit interviews offer insight into why officers choose to leave.
The two reports span a period of significant change within OPD. James Beere assumed department leadership in the July 2026, and Oakland’s federal police monitorship ended in September after more than two decades.2021
Concerns about discipline and federal oversight featured prominently in the earlier report. Those findings were consistent with a separate personnel survey published in July 2026, in which a majority of respondents questioned the fairness of OPD’s disciplinary process.22
The latest exit interviews raise different organizational concerns, including dissatisfaction with city or OPD leadership, work-life balance, and insufficient staffing and resources.
The latter is particularly significant. When staffing shortages increase workloads and limit available resources, they may also make it more difficult to retain the officers needed to resolve those shortages.
The changing rankings cannot be attributed directly to the leadership transition or the end of federal oversight. Nevertheless, they illustrate why retention depends on more than compensation or recruitment. Working conditions, organizational management, and employee confidence also matter.
When the roster overstates availability
Oakland’s staffing challenges extend beyond recruitment and attrition. Of OPD’s 612 sworn personnel, 71 were on long-term leave and another 25 were assigned to modified duty. That leaves 516 officers who were neither on leave nor modified duty, although not all would necessarily be available for patrol.
Medical leave accounts for most long-term absences, with the majority involving injuries sustained on duty. In October, OPD reported that 21 officers had been on medical leave for more than a year, including five for more than two years.
At an October 15 press conference,23 chief James Beere described the strain on the remaining workforce:
“The less cops we have means the more cops we break.”
— Oakland police chief James Beere, Oct. 15, 2026
Beere explained that staffing shortages require officers to work overtime and cover multiple assignments, while OPD continues to rely on assistance from the Alameda County Sheriff’s Office and California Highway Patrol.
His remarks highlight a potential cycle: staffing shortages increase demands on available officers, while injuries and prolonged absences further strain the workforce. Although OPD’s data do not establish a causal relationship between overtime and on-duty injuries, the challenge extends beyond filling vacancies to keeping officers healthy and available for duty.
The challenge ahead
Oakland is not alone in struggling to rebuild its police force. An April 2026 report from the Public Policy Institute of California found that statewide sworn staffing remained below pre-pandemic levels, amid ongoing recruitment and retention challenges.24
There are signs of recovery elsewhere. San Francisco hired 225 officers in 2025, achieving a net gain of 36 after six consecutive years of staffing declines.25 Nationally, a 2026 Police Executive Research Forum survey found that participating agencies increased staffing by 1.4% in 2025, despite rising retirements.26
Oakland has expanded recruitment and resumed funding academies, but sustained staffing growth remains elusive. As the city’s own projections anticipated, new officers are barely keeping pace with departures. Additional academies are an important part of rebuilding the department, but their impact depends on successful recruitment, graduation, and retention.
Rebuilding OPD will take years, not months. Reversing years of staffing losses requires addressing the interconnected challenges of recruitment, training, retention, and workforce availability — a complex undertaking that will demand sustained commitment well beyond any single budget cycle.
Related stories:

Oakland Report is an experiment in a new form of media: reasoned, data-driven, well-sourced analysis focused on observable and verifiable evidence. We present the facts and let the reader decide. Learn more at oaklandreport.org/about.
Alameda County Registrar of Voters. “City of Oakland Measure NN: Oakland community violence reduction and emergency response act of 2024.” Nov. 5, 2024 general election measure information, part 1, section 6. https://acvote.alamedacountyca.gov/acvote-assets/02_election_information/PDFs/20241105/en/Measures/32%20-%20Measure%20NN%20-%20City%20of%20Oakland%20-%20Citywide%20Violence%20Reduction%20Services.pdf
Beere, James P. “OPD staffing report.” City of Oakland Public Safety Committee meeting, Nov. 17, 2026. https://oakland.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=16140822&GUID=95726733-325E-4791-9EDE-9FF07388455F
Roseman, Erin. “Fiscal year 2024-25 third quarter revenue and expenditures report.” City of Oakland Finance Department, May 14, 2025. https://www.oaklandca.gov/files/assets/city/v/1/finance/documents/financial-reporting/revenue-amp-expenditure-reports/fy-2024-25-q3-re-report.pdf
City of Oakland. “FY 2024-25 budget balancing.” Agenda report to the mayor and city council, Dec. 5, 2024. https://www.oaklandca.gov/files/assets/city/v/1/public-meetings/public-ethics-commission/2024/view-report-and-attachments-a-and-b-and-exhibit-1-2.pdf
City of Oakland. “Fiscal year 2025-27 budget.” City of Oakland, Jun. 3, 2025. https://www.oaklandca.gov/files/assets/city/v/1/finance/documents/fiscal-years/2025-2027-budget/fy25-27-errata-budget-book-final-6.3.25-reduced-size.pdf
City of Oakland. “OPD reassigns traffic officers to strengthen patrol coverage.” Oakland Police Department news release, Sept. 19, 2025. https://www.oaklandca.gov/News-Releases/Police/OPD-Reassigns-Traffic-Officers-to-Strengthen-Patrol-Coverage
PFM Financial Advisors LLC et al. “Oakland Police Department baseline organizational and staffing review.” City of Oakland Office of the Inspector General, Dec. 2024. https://www.oaklandca.gov/files/assets/city/v/1/inspector-general/documents/published-reports/pfm-llc-opd-staffing-study.pdf
Roseman, Erin. “FY 2025-27 proposed budget development questions/responses #1.” City of Oakland Finance Department memorandum to the mayor and city council, Jun. 6, 2025. https://oakland.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=14274776&GUID=D0AAD253-CEE6-44B8-B0C7-BAC46B2AB32E
City of Oakland. “Police officer hiring process.” Oakland Police Department webpage, accessed Nov. 20, 2026. https://www.oaklandca.gov/Public-Safety-Streets/Police/Join-the-Oakland-Police-Department-OPD/Police-Officer-Hiring-Process
City of Oakland. “10-19-26 Oakland public safety planning and oversight commission.” City of Oakland public meetings webpage, Oct. 19, 2026. https://www.oaklandca.gov/Public-Meetings/Oakland-Public-Safety-Planning-and-Oversight-Commission/2026/10-19-26-Oakland-Public-Safety-Planning-and-Oversight-Commission
City of Oakland. “Public safety planning & oversight commission.” Meeting video recording, Oct. 19, 2026. https://oakland.granicus.com/MediaPlayer.php?publish_id=2441c205-d703-11f1-9c50-005056a84798
DeBenedetti, Katie. “Oakland passes new budget that keeps fire station open, boosts police staffing.” KQED, Jun. 11, 2025. https://www.kqed.org/news/12043553/alternative-oakland-budget-aims-to-halt-fire-station-closures-boost-police-staffing
City of Oakland. “OPD staffing report.” Special public safety committee meeting, Nov. 17, 2026, agenda item #4, file #27-0198. https://oakland.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?ID=1460149&GUID=47C3B0DF-ACBF-4A41-8594-DC7D66F89E56&Options=info%7C&Search=
City of Oakland. “Join the Oakland Police Department (OPD).” Oakland Police Department webpage, accessed Nov. 20, 2026. https://www.oaklandca.gov/Public-Safety-Streets/Police/Join-the-Oakland-Police-Department-OPD
Hassan, Anser. “Oakland police team up with Merritt College with pre-academy program aiming to recruit more officers.” ABC7 News, Nov. 26, 2025. https://abc7news.com/post/oakland-police-department-teams-merritt-college-pre-academy-program-aiming-recruit-more-officers/18215150/
City of Oakland. “Police department application help.” Oakland Police Department webpage, accessed Nov. 20, 2026. https://www.oaklandca.gov/Public-Safety-Streets/Police/Join-the-Oakland-Police-Department-OPD/Application-Help
City of Oakland. “Police cadet hiring.” Oakland Police Department webpage, accessed Nov. 20, 2026. https://www.oaklandca.gov/Public-Safety-Streets/Police/Join-the-Oakland-Police-Department-OPD/Police-Cadet-Hiring
City of Oakland. “Police officer (lateral).” City of Oakland job announcement, Sept. 29, 2026. https://www.governmentjobs.com/careers/oaklandca/jobs/5489149/police-officer-lateral
Beere, James. “OPD staffing report.” Oakland Police Department agenda report, Mar. 9, 2026. https://oakland.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=15312276&GUID=C600736B-28EA-4705-A4C2-F593A5EF64C5
City of Oakland. “James P. Beere sworn in as chief of Oakland Police Department.” City of Oakland news release, Jul. 29, 2026. https://www.oaklandca.gov/News-Releases/James-P.-Beere-Sworn-In-As-Chief-of-Oakland-Police-Department
Mandal, Rajni. “As the NSA ends, the conversation returns to Oakland.” Rajni Mandal’s Public Safety Updates, Sept. 30, 2026. https://rajnimandal.substack.com/p/as-the-nsa-ends-the-conversation
City of Oakland. “2025 IA perceptions survey report.” Oakland Police Department Office of Internal Accountability, Jul. 2026. https://www.oaklandca.gov/files/assets/city/v/1/police/documents/opd-policies-and-resources/office-of-internal-accountability/2026/final-2025-ia-perceptions-survey-report-july-2026.pdf
Oakland Police Department. “News conference October 15, 2026.” Oakland Police Department YouTube channel, Oct. 15, 2026. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kyiiKa-8TNc
Martin, Brandon et al. “Policy brief: understanding trends in law enforcement staffing.” Public Policy Institute of California, Apr. 2026. https://www.ppic.org/publication/policy-brief-understanding-trends-in-law-enforcement-staffing/
Hernandez, David. “SFPD sees biggest hiring surge in years after recruitment slump. This is why.” San Francisco Chronicle, Mar. 22, 2026. https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/san-francisco-police-officer-recruit-22085556.php
Police Executive Research Forum. “PERF national survey shows police staffing rebounds to its 2022 level as agencies employ new hiring strategies.” PERF Trending, May 23, 2026. https://perf.memberclicks.net/trending23may26







This is real journalism at its finest. Unlike anything you’ll find in the Bay Area mainstream media.