Letters to the Editor is a curated selection of the thoughts, ideas, observations and questions we receive from Oakland Report readers. The selections are ones that we, the editors, find interesting, noteworthy, or otherwise worth elevating in a formal letters column. This edition of Letters includes reader comments from our social media accounts.
Follow us on social
Instagram ∙ X / Twitter ∙ Facebook ∙ Nextdoor ∙ Threads ∙ Reddit
Barbara Lee promised to find Oakland’s “waste, fraud and abuse” – she hasn’t delivered yet.
Re: Barbara Lee promised to find Oakland’s “waste, fraud and abuse,” Nov. 10
If she assigns people to look at it they will have to report back their findings and she doesn’t want what everyone suspects to become known. Like do people seriously believe the Duongs [owners of Oakland’s recycling contractor], longtime fixtures in Oakland politics only became corrupt when dealing with Sheng Thao? They’ve been there for a long time and understand well pay-to-play. There are others with similar longtime histories in Oakland politics as well. Hell, just looking at the nonprofits of some city council members would raise eyebrows.
@economy-intention-56
on Reddit
Waste and inefficiency are the bigger problem
Re: Barbara Lee promised to find Oakland’s “waste, fraud and abuse,” Nov. 10
Many of the comments here focus on corruption, but I think that waste and inefficiency are a much, much bigger problem in Oakland. The standards and expectations are low. (OUSD being a prime example.) I don’t know how we clean that up. For many reasons, we can’t fire and replace all the employees. But if we keep the very people who built this system and have supported it for decades – not just at the top, but at every level – there’s little hope of improvement.
@affectionate-one-700
on Reddit
No solutions to structural deficit
Re: Barbara Lee promised to find Oakland’s “waste, fraud and abuse,” Nov. 10
The budget was a top 2025 mayoral election issue. Lee never included the budget on her campaign page & never proposed solutions to the structural deficit. Has she since then? Voters defeated the tax measure in 2025 but passed the charter amendment. Voters not seeing the link?
@fruitvalelocal
on Twitter / X
Help us reach our goal of 10,000 subscribers
$62 million in city grants with no defined purpose
Re: Oakland approved $61 million… with no public review, Oct. 30
This is completely outrageous. In addition to these questionable contracts, the Budget Advisory Committee identified $62 million in grants/contracts with no defined purpose. Two of them were for $5 million each! How can a city that declares a fiscal emergency so they can misappropriate taxpayer money, also be writing $5 million blank checks?
Evan Morgan
on Nextdoor
A shame that Lee refused to address her relationship with the Duongs
Re: Barbara Lee promised to find Oakland’s “waste, fraud and abuse,” Nov. 10
The Duongs have been donating to Barbara Lee since the late ’90s, only stopping after the Sheng Thao scandal came to light. That’s hardly a coincidence, and it’s an absolute shame that Barbara has refused to address the relationship when questioned about it.
@routine-addendum-170
on Reddit
The “strong mayor” system facilitates Trump-level corruption
Re: Oakland approved $61 million in contracts with no public review, Oct. 30
Under a strong mayor system, where a single politician controls the entire city administration, such a politician has considerably more leverage to engage in contracts with kickbacks and little public review. Measure EE [the “strong mayor reform”] facilitates the level of corruption that crooks like Trump would thrive in.
@miss_shivers
on Reddit
Rules for thee…
Re: Oakland approved $61 million in contracts with no public review, Oct. 30
How people think the rules work: if they award contracts greater than a certain threshold, they have to get our approval! How reality works:
“Each individual contract award came in below $250,000. Per city policy, contracts above $250,000 must be approved in advance by city council in a public meeting — where Oaklanders would get the chance to see and comment on them before they are signed.
“Our review of the list of contracts shows several apparent instances in which multiple individual contracts that cumulatively exceeded the $250,000 threshold were awarded to the same vendor in a single fiscal year.”
They just cut multiple checks for less than $250k to get around the rule. This city is full of corruption.
@sowed
on Reddit
…But not for me
Re: Barbara Lee promised to find Oakland’s “waste, fraud and abuse,” Nov. 10
Lee had enough time and money to hire a team to amend the city charter to give her strong mayor status and get Measure EE put on the ballot. There will be, magically, enough money to give worthless city council huge bumps in pay, but nothing for the promised audit.
@jm_zeigler
on Twitter / X
Share Oakland Report with someone you know.
Public safety solutions are left to the public and businesses themselves
Re: Why rebuilding Oakland’s police force is so difficult, Nov. 20, 2026
[Addressing another commenter] You bring up a really great point about community safety ambassadors. The City has actually allocated $2 million over two years (FY 2025–27) for Community Safety Ambassadors in commercial corridors, including $300,000 for the Laurel District Association. The Council approved the grants in November 2025.
There have been several studies of such programs that show real benefits — including Laurel and Montclair. It’s alternative programs such as these (which are usually paid for and run by the business improvement districts/BIDs) that definitely have a positive impact.
It’s also telling that in many instances, public safety solutions are left to the public and businesses themselves because of the lack of resources/funding from the city itself.
And yes — crime may be down in many categories, but property crime is still very high, with an extremely low clearance rate. There is a narrative in the community that since crime is down even though police staffing is down that we don’t need more police. I’m hoping that this article shows just how unsustainable current low staffing is — and how it’s support from other agencies as well as overtime that is filling the void (and which cannot do so forever).
Rajni Mandal
on Substack
Sensing renewed enthusiasm in OPD
Re: Why rebuilding Oakland’s police force is so difficult, Nov. 20, 2026
San Francisco has almost 1,900 police for one third of the real estate that OPD’s roughly 600 officers have to cover. That said, I think we need to give the Mayor a chance to fulfill these promises, especially since the Strong Mayor vote.
I’m optimistic, but haven’t put blinders on. I’m sensing a renewed enthusiasm in OPD since the Federal Monitor was lifted.
@opinionsareus
on Reddit
A fundamental conflict of interest
Re: Bruised but not broken: Oakland teachers union’s influence survives, Nov. 18, 2026
Bravo!
This should begin a larger conversation about the ‘special’ nature of public employee unions, ALL public employee unions, and the important differences from private sector unions.
Free speech is not negotiable. The right of employees to bargain with employers is not negotiable. The difference is with the nature of the ‘employer.’
Public employee unions keep arguing that their employer is just like the ‘evil’ business owner. But when voters and taxpayers look for that villain, they find themselves looking in a mirror! Keep following that logic and inevitably the voters and taxpayers become the ‘evil’ business owner refusing to be fair to employees.
Public employee unions must be able to negotiate a range of employment concerns with their employers. But they must not be allowed to select the elected officials that negotiate their compensation and benefits. That is a fundamental ‘Conflict of Interest’.
Gaming a commercial transaction in favor of one side is the definition of ‘corruption.’
Behind this issue is the larger issue of adequate support for education. Our democracy and our society must have stronger educational systems to support the future. More money is needed. But some of the need can be met with professional management and budgeting free from public union corruption of elections. This can be done while protecting most union rights. And it will boost public support and remove many of the anti-funding arguments at election time. It only requires the parties to restore balance and put the kids first.
RJ Phillips
on Substack
Virtually all large public agencies are run by public employee unions
Re: Bruised but not broken: Oakland teachers union’s influence survives, Nov. 18, 2026
I know I have said this several times. Maybe a link to it will save time in the future: Virtually all larger, urban public agencies, whether it’s BART, EBMUD, EBRPD, City of Oakland, or OUSD, are run by their own public employees unions. Nobody else is so motivated to pump tens of thousands of dollars into local Council or Board races. And consequently the elected officials pay back the unions that put them in office. The payback is in the form of wages, benefits and work rules that make the agency more expensive and less effective than it would otherwise be.
The campaign money comes out of the automatic pipeline from union dues to political action committees and on to the candidate.
In 2012 as Proposition 32, there was a statewide effort to interrupt the pipeline by prohibiting the automatic contribution to the PAC. Of course voluntary contributions would be allowed. Prop 32 got 43% of the vote in spite of being massively outspent by the unions.
The union dominance that the current Oakland Report article is criticizing will continue indefinitely unless there’s another but successful attempt to do another Prop 32 or equivalent.statewide initiative.
Otherwise the deck will remain stacked against the public.
Mike Henn
on Substack
Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires” want to turn schools into… data centers?
Re: Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires”... turn schools into data centers, Oct. 28
You have it all wrong. Bachelor and Brouhard are thinking outside the box on how to solve OUSD’s fiscal problems without closing half-empty schools. 😂
They will get the state legislature to exempt OUSD from all the state laws that have been on the books for years, governing the lease or sale of public property, and especially school property, then we can lease half or more of a bunch of school buildings to data centers at high market rates. Use their lease payments to cover the cost of keeping classrooms and playgrounds open in the rest of each building, and even make a profit to contribute to other OUSD schools.
Absolutely brilliant.
Len Raphael
on Substack
Brutally effective politics
Re: Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires”... turn schools into data centers, Oct. 28
Classic Oakland politics: just say “billionaires” or “tech bros” and the argument stops right there. A large chunk of the electorate won’t even bother to examine the claim past that. Got to give them credit, it’s brutally effective politics… I will say: the fact that they are resorting to these kinds of arguments indicates that they are worried about losing.
@stycasy
on Reddit
Weird, dishonest and desperate
Re: Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires”... turn schools into data centers, Oct. 28
Very weird, dishonest and desperate behavior. “Progressives” do ANYTHING to win elections (lie, cheat, even kill) because they have no real world skills.
Seneca Scott
on Substack
Same as right-wing paranoia and fearmongering
Re: Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires”... turn schools into data centers, Oct. 28
It’s the same level of thoughtless paranoia and fearmongering that many on the extreme right are victims of. But somehow, it’s OK because these people have those “In this house...” signs in their front yard.
@lazarusriley
on Reddit
Left-wing “Trumpism”
Re: Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires”... turn schools into data centers, Oct. 28
It’s just sad, sad word salad because they cannot point to a solid record of governance or excellence. It’s left-wing Trumpism. And it will probably work because the teacher union political base is so strong. Would be funny except it’s really happening.
@undertow9
on Reddit
Turn any popular propaganda to their cause
Re: Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires”... turn schools into data centers, Oct. 28
Standard operation from OEA. They will turn any popular propaganda talking point and try to leverage it for their cause. For years they have been using the emotional issue of shutting down schools to parlay into getting rid of the pro parent / pro student board and replacing it with a pro-OEA board whose major purpose was to just oust the OUSD admin who had guided OUSD out of state receivership.
@radiant-brain-9384
on Reddit
Everything but improving the education system
Re: Oakland school board incumbents claim “billionaires”... schools into data centers, Oct. 28
It’s like the school board wants to talk about everything other than improving the education system here in Oakland. Frankly, it’s embarrassing. Even the Richmond school district set improvement goals, and steadily worked toward them. Meanwhile here in Oakland, we’re talking conspiracy theories and pointing the blame at billionaires now?
@winstonchurshill
on Reddit
The views expressed in the Letters column do not necessarily reflect the views of Oakland Report or its contributing authors. Letters may be edited for clarity, length, and conciseness.
Follow us on social
Instagram ∙ X / Twitter ∙ Facebook ∙ Nextdoor ∙ Threads ∙ Reddit
Editors’ note
We recognize and love that Oakland is a complex city of nearly half a million people with so many unique lived experiences and perspectives. It’s what makes Oakland so beautiful. In that spirit, we don’t need to agree with every viewpoint we share in Letters. However, we also don’t have the time, space, or inclination to publish letters that are not helpful or that don’t meet our standards.
We appreciate readers’ comments on the topics we cover in Oakland Report, and observations about Oakland politics and governance in general. We welcome letters that are grounded in reason and evidence that can be rationally examined. We may respond to some letters. We may reject some letters. We may fact-check some letters. Other letters we may let speak for themselves. Write to us at letters@citizensoakland.org.
If you like our work, please consider donating. We are a volunteer-run, 501(c)(3) charitable nonprofit organization based in beautiful Oakland, California. Our mission is to make truth more accessible to all Oakland residents through deep investigative reporting and evidence-based analysis of local issues.
Your donation of any amount helps us continue our work to produce articles like the ones our readers wrote about in this column.
Thank you.
📖



