7 Comments
User's avatar
RJ Philips's avatar

Bravo!

This should begin a larger conversation about the 'special' nature of public employee unions, ALL public employee unions, and the important differences from private sector unions.

Free speech is not negotiable. The right of employees to bargain with employers is not negotiable. The difference is with the nature of the 'employer.'

Public employee unions keep arguing that their employer is just like the 'evil' business owner. But when voters and taxpayers look for that villain, they find themselves looking in a mirror! Keep following that logic and inevitably the voters and taxpayers become the 'evil' business owner refusing to be fair to employees.

Public employee unions must be able to negotiate a range of employment concerns with their employers. But they must not be allowed to select the elected officials that negotiate their compensation and benefits. That is a fundamental 'Conflict of Interest'.

Gaming a commercial transaction in favor of one side is the definition of 'corruption.'

Behind this issue is the larger issue of adequate support for education. Our democracy and our society must have stronger educational systems to support the future. More money is needed. But some of the need can be met with professional management and budgeting free from public union corruption of elections. This can be done while protecting most union rights. And it will boost public support and remove many of the anti-funding arguments at election time. It only requires the parties to restore balance and put the kids first.

Rex Allen's avatar

I hear you, Sean. Let’s throw the bums out (to coin a cliche)!

Rex Allen's avatar

As long as Oakland voters diligently keep their heads in the sand, the teachers unions will fleece them, as they have decade after the decade. It’s all so easy: Pretend the teachers aren’t paid well enough as their salaries skyrocket, as test and comprehension scores plummet, again and again. And of course, throw in charges of “racism” - something that hasn’t existed in BLACK-run Oakland for fifty years.

To paraphrase PT Barnum, “There are suckers born every election!”

Sean S. Reinhart's avatar

Rex, thank you for your comment, but Oakland voters are not to blame when they cast their votes based on lies and misinformation — which OEA and its supporters frequently deployed in this election, with little consequence. Thank you again, the discussion is appreciated.

Rex Allen's avatar

Has anyone tabulated how well Mindy did in the mayoral election? Somehow, it’s eluded me..

Thanks.

Rex Allen's avatar

Au contraire….

To the extent school bonds are passed by Oakland voters, the Oakland school board and its union shills are elected by the voters of Oakland, the City Council is elected by the voters of Oakland — and since both entities have the fiduciary responsibility of running the the fiscal matters honestly — it’s therefore 💯 the fault of Oakland VOTERS.

Sean S. Reinhart's avatar

Rex, thank you for explaining your views about voters, but they are only half-baked. Politicians love it when people blame voters for a public agency’s problems, because it lets the ones who are actually responsible — the politicians and the entities that back and influence them — off the hook when they perform poorly. At the end of the day, voters don’t make decisions— politicians and their backers do. Discouraging competitors, confusing and misleading the electorate, then blaming voters when things go wrong, is the stock-in-trade of today’s entrenched political machinery.