7 Comments
User's avatar
RJ Philips's avatar

As long as the money behind corporate and labor-nonprofit corruption keeps misleading voters that ‘the other guy does it so it’s ok,’ we will continue to see our public services deteriorate and our elections dominated by demands for more tax money. It shouldn’t matter where the stolen tax money is being diverted. It’s up to us voters to defend our tax dollars by electing responsible adults and holding them accountable. The left-right blame game is just Kabuki theater to distract us. Look behind the curtain.

Mindy Pechenuk's avatar

Thank you Charlene and Oakland Report. This corruption has to stop. Oakland needs new and better leaders. Our children deserve a real education and a future. They are our future. Mindy Pechenuk, for Oakland Mayor 2026

Sean S. Reinhart's avatar

Peter, thank you for your comment, but it is not germane to this article. This article is about OUSD board member VanCedric Williams, his apparent failure to disclose the compensation he receives from CTA, and his decision not to recuse himself from voting on a union contact that has material benefits to CTA -- and by extension, himself.

The author provides extensive evidence and documentation -- including Williams' and CTA's own financial filings -- to support the article's findings. Readers can examine them and decide for themselves what to think about it.

Regarding corporate interests and influence in politics: two days ago, Oakland Report was the first to publish the full transcript of a recorded phone call between Andy Duong, executive at California Waste Solutions (a for-profit corporation) and a local council member in which Duong spoke of his influence over various local politicians to benefit his businesses. Duong is currently standing trial for bribery and corruption.

Earlier this week, Oakland Report was the first to publish an in-depth examination of the California Trucking Association's (a trade group that represents the for-profit trucking industry) political influence and lobbying of state legislators and Caltrans seeking to lift a decades-long ban on heavy trucks on Interstate 580 in Oakland.

If you have specific examples of errors or bias in this article about VanCedric Williams and California Teacher's Association, then please share them. But we assert that this article is not biased, and the burden of proof is on the person making the assertion that it is.

Thank you again for your comment, and for reading Oakland Report; the discussion is very much appreciated.

Nathan Willis's avatar

Educator representation on boards actoss the country is lacking at best. It is often overseen by business interests and people who have no background in education. Pro-Union sentiment is hard to find in this day in age precisely because disinformation of this kind. The article even states that this is common practice to reimburse the salaries of union staff and elected positions within the CTA. The hatred of teachers receiving fair compensation for the difficult work of education is laughable, and they still cannot live comfortably in the cities in which they work. The holes in district budgets come from their inability to properly spend Covid-19 limited funds in a LIMITED MANNER. You should be focusing on their consultant pay, pay to ouside organizations, and their mismanagement of funds paid to district office personnel. Teacher's have little representation as it is. And you're article takes common practice and highlights it as malfeasance. Ludicrous given the state of the country, prices of goods and services, and the failure of this Nation to properly defend public servants and their role in educating our children.

Sean S. Reinhart's avatar

Nathan— Thank you for your comment. What, specifically in the article do you find factually inaccurate or misleading? Based on the facts documented in the article, do you agree with the board member’s actions, and why or why not?

Peter's avatar

how about school board and council members who are supported by donations for corporate interest. i don't see much of that reported here or by empower oakland. your biases show on every post

Sean S. Reinhart's avatar

Peter, thank you for your comment, but it is not germane to this article. This article is about OUSD board member VanCedric Williams, his apparent failure to disclose the compensation he receives from CTA, and his decision not to recuse himself from voting on a union contact that has material benefits to CTA -- and by extension, himself.

The author provides extensive evidence and documentation -- including Williams' and CTA's own financial filings -- to support the article's findings. Readers can examine them and decide for themselves what to think about it.

Regarding corporate interests and influence in politics: two days ago, Oakland Report was the first to publish the full transcript of a recorded phone call between Andy Duong, executive at California Waste Solutions (a for-profit corporation) and a local council member in which Duong spoke of his influence over various local politicians to benefit his businesses. Duong is currently standing trial for bribery and corruption.

Earlier this week, Oakland Report was the first to publish an in-depth examination of the California Trucking Association's (a trade group that represents the for-profit trucking industry) political influence and lobbying of state legislators and Caltrans seeking to lift a decades-long ban on heavy trucks on Interstate 580 in Oakland.

If you have specific examples of errors or bias in this article about VanCedric Williams and California Teacher's Association, then please share them. But we assert that this article is not biased, and the burden of proof is on the person making the assertion that it is.

Thank you again for your comment, and for reading Oakland Report; the discussion is very much appreciated.